Why is it More Complicated to Set Up Microphones to Record a Piano Recital, Than Other Instruments?

Recording techniques will naturally tend to vary, givenside of the piano. This is a common position in concert
the instrument being recorded, as well as the conditionshall environments as well.
of the environment- being the room, hall, or auditorium.However, care should still be taken in microphone
There are many published books on recordingplacement, as if the mics are too close, the resulting
techniques for individual instruments and orchestras, butaudio will be a little harsh, whereas if they are moved
pianos have always been a more challengingback a bit, they will also pick up an overall reflection,
experience, given the varied designs, lengths (rangingfrom the room, as well as the piano's 'base' sound. In
from 1.6 meters to 3 meters), and possible orientationsaddition, you need to look at the style of mic units you
of the piano. By this, I am referring to the front of thewant to use. Would you prefer a stereo condenser
upper lid, being open, just behind the music board, orpair, as two separate mics, or rather an integrated unit,
the whole lid open at thirty degrees, or evenbut placed at different points around, and above the
completely off. These factors alone, will dramaticallypiano?
influence the end result of the sound, given variedI will not be so up front in suggesting a certain position
microphone placement. So, where to from here?is the only way, as there are so many variables
To best answer this question, I think a little theory andinvolved, and it is this that makes the piano such a
understanding of the piano's design concept is required.challenging, yet rewarding musical instrument to mic. An
Every piano string has a given, fundamental frequency,engineer who gets this right can certainly be proud of
as well as harmonics, or side frequencies of the maintheir achievement. To explain and summarise this point
frequency. In many cases, the harmonics will be asfurther, all pianos have different reflections and
loud (same level) as the fundamental frequency, butharmonics, due to the different lengths of the strings,
this does vary, over the span of the piano. Forand as each piano can be a varied size, these
instance, the lower notes will tend to have a harmonicreflections and harmonics, not to mention levels, will
frequency that is considerably louder than thevary. Unlike a maths equation, I can't provide a specific
fundamental frequency, by as much as just overformula, and then fill in the blanks. However, by
twenty deciBells (dB), whereas with the higherappreciating these variables, and with practice, the
frequency strings, the harmonics can be quite a bitprocess will become easier to master.
lower in volume, but still contribute significantly to theI would suggest, as a start, that you have a mic, a little
overall sound of the piano.above the middle C strings, towards the front of the
On top of this, the characteristics will vary, given thepiano, as well as a mic just inside, and over the upper
position of the piano covers. This point is probably fairlystrings, as well as a mic picking up the rear, and front
obvious, given that the reflections off the wood withleft of the piano. All in all, a total of four positions
the cover on, or even open at thirty degrees, willcovered. This configuration assumes a large enough
significantly direct the sound a certain way, typicallymixing desk is used, as well as enough tracks, if using
above, and just to the front of the piano. On the otheran individual track, and mix it down system, or of
hand, with the entire top cover removed from a grandcourse, a live mix, straight to stereo mode.
piano, all the sound waves will tend to direct upwards,Again, the complexity is very much limited by your
with little reflection towards the side of the piano, andbudget, and equipment. However, it should be noted
substantially alter the resulting sound.that even one, good quality, condenser microphone
In my experience, the best results have been achieved,can do a very good job, if placed well. However, each
with a grand piano, when the top cover has beenpiano, and environment will force a need for trial and
open to about thirty degrees, and the sound is able toerror to get it right. The advantage of multiple tracking
reflect off the cover, to 'radiate' around the front, andis that you will be able to play with the mix later on.