The Eternal Argument - Digital Vs Acoustic

The acoustic piano was for a long time thesecond hand can be a risky business.
centrepiece of the drawing room of the upper classes.Still, most proficient pianists say that the sound, which is
It featured in the Jane Austen type books, and virtuallyafter all the end product of the playing of a piano,
every daughter of that time and society had to addmakes all the expenses well worth while.
the playing of the piano to her accomplishments.Unfortunately, most ordinary pianists cannot justify the
However, ongoing technology has resulted in a host ofhigh costs of purchase and maintenance and so are
digital pianos, which now have the look and feel of theincreasingly turning ti the digital option.
acoustic version, and as a result, people in the marketTHE DIGITAL PIANO
for a new piano now have the choice of digital orThe digital piano tries to match the sound of an
acoustic.acoustic piano electronically. The depression of the
Both types have their advantages and disadvantages.keys does not move a hammer mechanically, it emits
THE ACOUSTIC PIANOa pre-recorded sound of that note played acoustically.
The acoustic piano is a marvelously made mechanicalIn comparison to an acoustic piano, a digital piano will
contraption. When a key is pressed it causes abe much cheaper.
muffled hammer to strike the strings in the body of theSome say that an electronic piano doesn't have the
piano, which causes the rich piano sound which somesame "touch" as an acoustic one, but while this may
say cannot be replicated electronically.have been true in the early days, instruments from
However an acoustic piano does need a lot of room,manufacturers such as Yamaha have addressed this
which was fine in the huge rooms of stately homes,problem.
but which will not be the case in the reduced living areaIf you are a professional pianist, an acoustic piano is
of a small house or apartment.probably out of the question. You are faced with either
A major consideration, even if you do have the room,lugging a very heavy piece of equipment to the venue,
is that the piano needs to be delivered to its final placewhich is probably not an option at all, or putting up with
in the room. Pianos are extremely heavy objects, andone at the venue itself, which may be of dubious
normally need a team of specialist piano removers toquality.
shift them. There is also the consideration of theVirtually every musician playing gigs these days has a
access to the room - if there is a tight stairwell it maydigital pianos or keyboard, as they are generally easily
be impossible to get the piano to where you want it totransportable.
go.An upmarket digital piano contains many additional
There is also the ongoing cost of regular tuning to getfeatures. Not only can it play the basic piano sound, but
the best out of the instrument. Pianos regularly losehas an array of other sounds. These include a drum
their tuning, for example when being transported, oraccompaniment, so that a pianist playing an electronic
sometimes even with changes in the weather.instrument may not need any other musicians at all.
Then there is the initial cost. Acoustic pianos areFinally of course digital pianos do not need ongoing
generally very expensive to buy new, and buyingtuning.